During WWI this sailor saved his fellow mate from noxious toilet fumes — earning him the Medal of Honor

Published: 17 February 2026

By Jon Guttman
via the Military Times website

USS New York underway May 29, 1915

The USS New York underway on May 29, 1915. (National Archives)

Little is known of Wilhelm Smith’s background, save that he was born on April 10, 1870, in a German Empire that would formally unite in the following year. Since then, he emigrated to the United States and enlisted in the U.S. Navy. By January 1916, he was serving as a gunner’s mate third class aboard the battleship New York (BB-34), one of the most up-to-date and powerful warships of its kind. For all that, though, New York was served by a variety of seamen and engineers in an often claustrophobic labyrinth of chambers and passageways. On Jan. 24, 1916, one of New York’s crews within a crew were reminded of how dangerous even a routine procedure could be.

The Great War in Europe was raging at that time, but the United States was still neutral, with the New York helping to maintain that neutrality. Amid all the maintenance activity, Coxswain W.L. Campbell, in charge of the 1st Division, ordered the sanitary tank in section A12 opened for cleaning by three crewmen.

Of them, P. J. Walsh, J. Paone, and L. L. Nerling thought the tank sufficiently ventilated, but plumber R.M. Traynor, upon examining the train and suction valves, judged the air still too foul. At the same time, Smith led another sailor, Peter G. Walsh into the handling room. They also thought their room sufficiently aired out — until Smith discovered that Walsh was unresponsive and jammed in the cramped quarters below, overcome by the fumes.

Besides the difficulty that presented itself dislodging Walsh from the handling room, Smith himself faced extraordinary difficulty going down there, being of stocky build and 192 pounds. Regardless, he procured a rope, which he tied around Walsh and passed his limp body out of the room — only to be himself overcome by the fumes. Fortunately, his fellow crewmen retrieved him and rushed him and Walsh to the sick bay, where they were resuscitated.

Word of Smith’s rescue of Walsh spread throughout the ship, leading to a citation from the 1st Division officer: Navy General Order — New York:

“Peter J. Walsh, ordinary seaman, undoubtedly owes his life to the prompt and heroic action of Wilhelm Smith, gunner’s mate, first class, who unhesitatingly risked his own in order save that of his shipmate. Such action is a shining example of fearlessness, unselfishness, and heroism, and merits the highest commendation and praise. It is recommended that the department award Smith a medal of honor…”

Smith was awarded the Medal of Honor on April 6, 1916 — a somewhat ironic date, since exactly one year later his adopted country declared war on the nation he’d left behind. For the next year and a half after that, New York patrolled the Atlantic Ocean against German submarines, disguised raiders and other enemy warships.

Read the entire article on the Military Times website here:

External Web Site Notice: This page contains information directly presented from an external source. The terms and conditions of this page may not be the same as those of this website. Click here to read the full disclaimer notice for external web sites. Thank you.

Share this article

Related posts